Roth vs Traditional IRA Calculator
Working
A Roth IRA is funded with money that has already been taxed, so the withdrawals in retirement are tax-free. A traditional IRA is funded with pre-tax money, so the withdrawals are taxed. Which one leaves more money depends on the tax rate now and the tax rate in retirement: if the rate in retirement is lower, the traditional IRA usually wins, and if it is the same, they tie. A $7,000 contribution growing at 7% for 30 years becomes $53,285.79. At a 22% rate now and a 12% rate in retirement, the traditional IRA leaves $46,891.49 after tax and the Roth leaves $41,562.91. At 22% in both cases, both leave $41,562.91. This calculator works out both figures from the rates you put in.
What this calculator does
This calculator answers which IRA leaves more money after tax. You put in the contribution, the years until withdrawal, the expected annual return, the tax rate now, and the tax rate in retirement, and this calculator works out the future value, the traditional IRA value after tax at the retirement rate, and the Roth value after tax at the current rate. It also explains that the comparison turns on the two tax rates, and that the income limits and the required minimum distributions aren't part of this comparison. It does not open an account.
How this is calculated
The future value is the contribution times one plus the return to the power of the years: $7,000 at 7% for 30 years is $7,000 times 1.07 to the power of 30, or $53,285.79. The traditional IRA pays tax on withdrawal, so its after-tax value is the future value times one minus the retirement tax rate: at 12% that is $53,285.79 times 0.88, or $46,891.49. The Roth pays tax on the contribution, so its after-tax value is the contribution after tax, grown: $7,000 times 0.78 is $5,460, and $5,460 times 1.07 to the power of 30 is $41,562.91. At a 22% retirement rate the traditional IRA is $53,285.79 times 0.78, or $41,562.91, the same as the Roth.
Source
IRA rules are published by the Internal Revenue Service at irs.gov — Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs).
Limitations
This calculator assumes a constant return, no withdrawals before retirement, and no change in the tax rates. It does not cover the income limits for a Roth IRA, the deduction limits for a traditional IRA, the required minimum distributions, or the 10% early withdrawal penalty. For most people, it doesn't cover the tax on the growth inside the account, because both accounts grow tax-deferred. What you get is a comparison for planning, not tax advice.
What each input means
Contribution. The amount contributed in one year, in dollars. Years. The number of years until the money is withdrawn. Expected annual return. The return on the investments, as a percentage. Tax rate now. The marginal tax rate on the contribution, as a percentage. Tax rate in retirement. The expected marginal tax rate on withdrawals, as a percentage.
How to read your result
Read the two after-tax figures first, then the difference. A $7,000 contribution at 7% for 30 years, taxed at 22% now and 12% in retirement, leaves $46,891.49 in the traditional IRA and $41,562.91 in the Roth, so the traditional IRA is ahead by $5,328.58. At 22% in both cases, both leave $41,562.91 and the choice does not matter on tax alone. If the retirement rate is higher than the current rate, the Roth wins, because the tax is paid now at the lower rate.
Worked example
Take a $7,000 contribution, 30 years, a 7% return, a 22% rate now, and a 12% rate in retirement. The future value is $53,285.79. The traditional IRA after tax is $53,285.79 times 0.88, or $46,891.49. The Roth after tax is $5,460 grown at 7% for 30 years, or $41,562.91. The traditional IRA is ahead by $5,328.58. Take the same figures with a 22% retirement rate: the traditional IRA after tax is $53,285.79 times 0.78, or $41,562.91, the same as the Roth.
What to do next
Check the income limits, because a high income can block a Roth contribution or a traditional deduction, and check the required minimum distribution rules for a traditional IRA. The 401(k) calculator can work out the employer match, and the retirement withdrawal planner can test how long the savings last.
Common questions
Which is better, Roth or traditional?
It depends on the tax rates. If the retirement rate is lower, the traditional IRA usually wins. If it is the same, they tie. If it is higher, the Roth wins.
What if the tax rates are the same?
Both leave the same amount after tax. The choice then turns on the other rules, such as required minimum distributions.
Does the Roth have income limits?
Yes. For most people, a high income can block a direct Roth contribution, although a backdoor Roth may still be possible. It doesn't test the limits.
What about required minimum distributions?
A traditional IRA has them, and a Roth IRA does not for the owner. This tool does not model them.
Can I contribute to both?
Yes, up to the combined annual limit. This calculator compares one contribution in each.