BenefitBeacon

← All tools

1099 vs W-2 Take-Home Calculator

Working

The same $80,000 pays differently as 1099 income and as W-2 wages, because a self-employed worker pays both shares of payroll tax while an employee pays only one. On $80,000, the 1099 take-home pay is $52,339.76 and the W-2 take-home pay is $56,280, a difference of $3,940.24. Day to day, this calculator works out both figures from the income and the tax rate you put in, so the two kinds of work can be compared on the same pay. It doesn't cover the benefits a W-2 job usually includes, such as health insurance and paid time off, which are worth more than the tax difference.

Illustration of rising bars and a coin, representing 1099 vs w-2 take-home.

What this calculator does

This calculator answers how much more or less 1099 work pays than W-2 work. You put in the income and the tax rate, and it works out the 1099 take-home pay, with self-employment tax and income tax, and the W-2 take-home pay, with the employee payroll tax and income tax, and the difference. In practice, it also explains that the W-2 figure doesn't include the employer-paid benefits, which make the W-2 job worth more than the take-home pay alone. It doesn't negotiate the pay.

How this is calculated

For 1099 income, the self-employment tax base is 92.35% of net income, and the tax is 15.3% of the base: on $80,000 the base is $73,880 and the tax is $11,303.64. The income tax is 22% of the net income minus half the self-employment tax, or $16,356.60. The take-home pay is $80,000 minus $11,303.64 minus $16,356.60, or $52,339.76. For W-2 wages, the payroll tax is 7.65% of wages, or $6,120, and the income tax is 22% of $80,000, or $17,600. The take-home pay is $80,000 minus $6,120 minus $17,600, or $56,280. The difference is $56,280 minus $52,339.76, or $3,940.24.

Source

Self-employment tax is explained by the Internal Revenue Service at irs.gov — Self-Employment Tax.

Limitations

It uses the tax rate you put in as a flat rate, which is a simplification, and it doesn't include state tax. It doesn't value the benefits a W-2 job usually includes, such as health insurance, paid time off, and the employer 401(k) match, which can be worth thousands of dollars a year. Day to day, it doesn't cover business expenses, which reduce 1099 income, or the self-employed health insurance deduction. What you get is a tax comparison for planning, not a job decision.

What each input means

Income. The annual income, in dollars, the same for both kinds of work. Tax rate. The marginal federal income tax rate, as a percentage.

How to read your result

Read the two take-home figures first, then the difference. On $80,000 at 22%, the 1099 take-home pay is $52,339.76 and the W-2 take-home pay is $56,280, so the W-2 job pays $3,940.24 more after tax. The difference is the employer share of payroll tax, which the self-employed worker pays. But the W-2 job usually also includes health insurance and paid time off, so the real gap is larger than $3,940.24. A 1099 worker who can deduct business expenses or charge a higher rate can close the gap.

Worked example

Take $80,000 at a 22% tax rate. As 1099 income, the self-employment tax is $11,303.64 and the income tax is $16,356.60, so the take-home pay is $52,339.76. As W-2 wages, the payroll tax is $6,120 and the income tax is $17,600, so the take-home pay is $56,280. The W-2 job pays $3,940.24 more after tax. The quarterly estimated payment on the 1099 income is $6,915.06.

What to do next

If the choice is between a 1099 offer and a W-2 offer, add the value of the W-2 benefits to the comparison, and ask the 1099 client for a higher rate to cover the extra tax. The 1099 take-home planner can work out the quarterly payments, and the salary comparison calculator can compare two offers.

What to watch out for

The most common mistake when comparing 1099 and W-2 work is comparing only the pay. A 1099 worker pays the full self-employment tax of 15.3% on the net earnings, while a W-2 worker pays only half, with the employer paying the other half, so the same gross pay gives different take-home pay. The second most common mistake is forgetting the benefits: a W-2 job usually includes health insurance, paid leave, and a retirement match, while a 1099 worker must buy them, and the cost can be thousands of dollars a year. The third most common mistake is forgetting the expenses: a 1099 worker can deduct the business expenses, such as the mileage and the supplies, which cuts the taxable income, but only if the expenses are recorded. Keep the records, and set the tax money aside as it is earned, because the quarterly estimated taxes are due on 15 April, 15 June, 15 September, and 15 January. The 1099 take-home tax planner on this site can work out the 1099 taxes in detail.

Common questions

Why does 1099 pay less after tax?

Because a self-employed worker pays both shares of payroll tax, while an employee pays only one and the employer pays the other.

What about W-2 benefits?

Health insurance, paid time off, and the 401(k) match are usually worth thousands of dollars a year, on top of the tax difference.

Can a 1099 worker deduct expenses?

Yes. Business expenses reduce the net income and the tax. This calculator does not include them.

Should I ask for a higher 1099 rate?

Usually yes. A 1099 rate about 25% to 30% above the W-2 wage covers the extra tax and the missing benefits.

What about the quarterly payments?

A 1099 worker pays estimated tax four times a year. The 1099 planner on this site works out the amount.

Sources

Related guides

Official sources

Benefit rules, amounts and application steps come from the administering agency. These links open the official agency home page in a new tab. Program pages link to the agency named on the page.