COBRA vs ACA Comparison
Working
After a job loss, the choice is often between COBRA, which keeps the old employer plan, and an ACA marketplace plan, which is usually cheaper with a subsidy. COBRA keeps the same doctors and the same deductible progress, but the premium is the full cost, including the part the employer used to pay, plus a 2% fee, and it lasts at most 18 months. An ACA plan can be bought during the special enrollment period after a job loss, and the subsidy depends on the income. In practice, this comparison works out the total cost of each for the months needed, so the choice uses numbers, not on a guess. Losing a job is one of the events that decides who qualifies for ACA coverage outside open enrollment, and the subsidy — set by the ACA income limits for the household — decides how much the ACA side costs.
What this calculator does
This comparison answers which costs less: COBRA or an ACA marketplace plan. You put in the COBRA monthly premium, the ACA monthly premium after the subsidy, and the number of months needed, and this comparison works out the total cost of each and the difference. It also explains the trade-offs: COBRA keeps the same plan and doctors, while an ACA plan is usually cheaper but means a new plan, a new deductible, and possibly new doctors. It does not choose for you.
How this is calculated
Enter the COBRA monthly premium, which is the full premium including the employer’s share plus a 2% fee, and the ACA monthly premium after the subsidy, which the marketplace shows. Enter the number of months needed, up to 18 for COBRA. It multiplies each premium by the months and shows the totals and the difference. Then weigh the trade-offs: COBRA keeps the same plan, the same doctors, and the deductible progress, which matters if a lot of care has already been paid for this year. An ACA plan is usually cheaper, and the subsidy can make it much cheaper, but it means a new plan, a new deductible, and possibly new doctors. The special enrollment period after a job loss is usually 60 days, so don't wait.
Source
Compare plans at healthcare.gov, which shows the ACA premiums and the subsidy. The COBRA premium is on the COBRA election notice from the former employer.
Limitations
This comparison covers the premiums only; it does not cover the out-of-pocket costs, which depend on the care needed, or the deductible progress, which only COBRA keeps. The ACA premium must be the premium after the subsidy, from healthcare.gov. What you get is a cost comparison, not a recommendation.
What each input means
COBRA monthly premium. The full monthly premium from the COBRA election notice. ACA monthly premium. The monthly premium after the subsidy, from healthcare.gov. Months needed. The number of months of coverage needed, up to 18 for COBRA.
How to read your result
It shows the total cost of COBRA and the total cost of the ACA plan for the months needed, and the difference. Then weigh the trade-offs: COBRA keeps the same plan and doctors and the deductible progress, while the ACA plan is usually cheaper but means a new plan and a new deductible.
Worked example
Take a person who lost a job and needs six months of coverage. The COBRA premium is $650 a month, and the ACA premium after the subsidy is $250 a month. COBRA costs $650 × 6 = $3,900, and the ACA plan costs $250 × 6 = $1,500, so the ACA plan saves $2,400. If the person has already met the deductible on the employer plan and needs a lot of care, COBRA may still be worth it, because the ACA plan starts a new deductible. Otherwise the ACA plan is usually the cheaper choice.
What to do next
Apply within the 60-day special enrollment period, and check the subsidy on healthcare.gov before deciding. Day to day, the HMO vs PPO vs HDHP comparison can compare the plan types, and the bronze vs silver vs gold comparison can compare the metal levels.
What to watch out for
The most common mistake after a job loss is waiting too long to decide. In real terms, the special enrollment period for an ACA plan is usually 60 days after the job loss, and COBRA must be elected within 60 days of the notice, so the choice should be made quickly, not at the last minute. The second most common mistake is comparing only the premium: COBRA keeps the same plan, the same doctors, and the deductible progress, which matters if a lot of care has already been paid for this year, while an ACA plan starts a new deductible, so the out-of-pocket costs matter too. The third most common mistake is forgetting the subsidy: the ACA premium after the subsidy can be much lower than the premium before it, and the subsidy depends on the income, so check healthcare.gov for the real price. Do not let the coverage lapse, because a gap means paying the full cost of any care, and the coverage should be continuous. Check the doctors: if the ACA plan doesn't include the current doctors, COBRA may be worth the higher premium.
Common questions
What is COBRA?
A law that lets a person keep the old employer plan after a job loss, paying the full premium plus a 2% fee, for up to 18 months.
What is the ACA marketplace?
Healthcare.gov, where people buy health insurance, with a subsidy based on income.
How long do I have to decide?
Usually 60 days after the job loss, for the special enrollment period. Do not wait.
Does COBRA keep my deductible progress?
Yes. COBRA keeps the same plan, so the deductible progress stays. An ACA plan starts a new deductible.
Is the ACA plan always cheaper?
Usually, with the subsidy, but not always. Compare the premiums and the deductible progress before deciding.