BenefitBeacon

← All tools

Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare Comparison

Working

Medicare Advantage, or Part C, is a private plan that replaces Original Medicare, while Original Medicare is Parts A and B, usually with a Part D drug plan and a Medigap supplement. Medicare Advantage often has a low premium and includes drug coverage, dental, and vision, but it has a network and needs prior authorization for some care. Original Medicare lets the person see any doctor who takes Medicare, but it needs a Part D plan and a Medigap policy to cover the gaps, and those cost extra. This comparison works out the monthly cost of each from the premiums entered, so the premium cost is clear, and it explains the trade-offs.

Illustration of rising bars and a coin, representing medicare advantage vs original.

What this calculator does

This comparison answers which costs less in premiums: Medicare Advantage or Original Medicare with Part D and Medigap. You put in the Medicare Advantage monthly premium, the Part D monthly premium, and the Medigap monthly premium, and this comparison works out the monthly cost of each, including the standard Part B premium of $202.90 a month for 2026. For most people, it also explains the trade-offs: the network, the drug coverage, and the out-of-pocket maximum. It does not choose for you.

How this is calculated

Enter the Medicare Advantage monthly premium, the Part D monthly premium, and the Medigap monthly premium, from the plan documents or medicare.gov. This comparison adds the standard Part B premium of $202.90 a month for 2026 to both sides, because both choices need Part B, and adds the Part D and Medigap premiums to Original Medicare. Then weigh the trade-offs: Medicare Advantage often has a low premium and includes drug coverage, dental, and vision, but it has a network, needs prior authorization for some care, and has an out-of-pocket maximum. Original Medicare lets the person see any doctor who takes Medicare, and Medigap covers most of the gaps, but the Part D and Medigap premiums cost extra, and there is no out-of-pocket maximum on Original Medicare itself.

Source

Compare plans at medicare.gov. The standard Part B premium for 2026 is $202.90 a month (CMS).

Limitations

This comparison covers the premiums only; it does not cover the out-of-pocket costs, which depend on the care needed, or the drug costs, which depend on the prescriptions. The Part B premium shown is the standard 2026 premium; people with higher income pay more. What you get is a premium comparison, not a recommendation.

What each input means

Medicare Advantage monthly premium. The Part C plan’s monthly premium. Part D monthly premium. The drug plan’s monthly premium, for Original Medicare. Medigap monthly premium. The supplement’s monthly premium, for Original Medicare.

How to read your result

This comparison shows the monthly cost of each choice, including the standard Part B premium of $202.90. Then weigh the trade-offs: Medicare Advantage has a network and an out-of-pocket maximum, while Original Medicare lets the person see any doctor who takes Medicare but needs Part D and Medigap.

Worked example

Take a beneficiary comparing the two choices. The Medicare Advantage premium is $25 a month, the Part D premium is $40 a month, and the Medigap premium is $150 a month. Medicare Advantage costs $202.90 + $25 = $227.90 a month, and Original Medicare costs $202.90 + $40 + $150 = $392.90 a month, so Medicare Advantage costs $165 less a month in premiums. But the beneficiary must check the network, the drug coverage, and the out-of-pocket maximum, because the care costs can differ a lot.

What to do next

Check the network, the drug formulary, and the out-of-pocket maximum of the Medicare Advantage plan, and the Medigap plan’s coverage. In real terms, the Medicare plan comparison can compare the monthly costs in more detail, and the Medicare Part B premium calculator can work out the Part B premium with the income surcharge.

When each choice wins

Medicare Advantage usually wins when the monthly premium matters most, because the plan premium is often low, sometimes zero, and the drug coverage is usually included, along with dental and vision, so the monthly total is lower. The trade-off is the network: the person must use the plan’s doctors and hospitals, and some care needs prior authorization, which can delay it. Original Medicare usually wins when the choice of doctors matters most, because it lets the person see any doctor who takes Medicare, with no network and no referral, and Medigap covers most of the gaps, so the out-of-pocket costs are predictable. For most people, the price is the higher monthly premium, because the person pays for Part B, Part D, and Medigap. The choice depends on the doctors, the drugs, and the health: a person with a specialist they want to keep should check whether the specialist is in the Advantage plan’s network, and a person who takes expensive drugs should check the plan’s formulary. Compare the plans on medicare.gov during open enrollment, because the plans change every year, and the Medicare plan comparison on this site can compare the monthly costs.

Common questions

What is Medicare Advantage?

Part C: a private plan that replaces Original Medicare, often with drug, dental, and vision coverage.

What is Original Medicare?

Parts A and B, usually with a Part D drug plan and a Medigap supplement.

Do both need Part B?

Yes. Both choices need the Part B premium, which is $202.90 a month for 2026 for most people.

Does Medicare Advantage have a network?

Yes, usually. Original Medicare lets the person see any doctor who takes Medicare.

Is there an out-of-pocket maximum?

Medicare Advantage has one. Original Medicare itself does not, although Medigap covers most of the gaps.

Sources

Related guides

Official sources

Benefit rules, amounts and application steps come from the administering agency. These links open the official agency home page in a new tab. Program pages link to the agency named on the page.