First-Time Homebuyer Program Comparison
Working
First-time buyers can choose between several loan programs: FHA, conventional, VA, and USDA. They differ in the down payment, the mortgage insurance, and who qualifies. An FHA loan needs a down payment of 3.5% for most buyers and mortgage insurance. A conventional loan usually needs at least 3% to 5% down and private mortgage insurance if the down payment is under 20%. A VA loan needs no down payment for eligible veterans and service members, and no monthly mortgage insurance. A USDA loan needs no down payment for eligible rural homes. Day to day, this comparison works out the down payment of each for a home price, so the upfront cost is clear. Three of the four are homebuyer assistance programs — FHA, VA, and USDA — and the comparison puts them next to a conventional loan.
What this calculator does
This comparison answers what the down payment is for each program. You put in the home price, and it works out the down payment for FHA at 3.5%, conventional at 5%, VA at 0%, and USDA at 0%, and explains who qualifies for each and what mortgage insurance each needs. It does not cover the monthly payment, which depends on the rate and the term, and it does not choose for you.
How this is calculated
Enter the home price. This comparison works out the down payment for each program: FHA at 3.5% of the price, conventional at 5%, VA at 0%, and USDA at 0%. Then weigh the trade-offs. FHA is open to most buyers and needs a 3.5% down payment, plus mortgage insurance. Conventional is open to most buyers and needs at least 3% to 5% down, plus private mortgage insurance if the down payment is under 20%. VA is only for eligible veterans and service members, with no down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance, but it has a funding fee. USDA is only for eligible rural homes and incomes, with no down payment. Check the eligibility and the mortgage insurance before deciding.
Source
Compare the programs at hud.gov — Buying a Home. The FHA 3.5% down payment and the VA and USDA zero-down rules are the programs’ published terms.
Limitations
This comparison covers the down payment only; it doesn't cover the monthly payment, the mortgage insurance, or the funding fee, which must be checked with the lender. The conventional down payment shown is 5%, which is a common example, not a rule. What you get is a down payment comparison, not a recommendation.
What each input means
Home price. The price of the home, in dollars.
How to read your result
It shows the down payment for FHA, conventional, VA, and USDA for the home price. Then check the eligibility: VA is only for eligible veterans and service members, and USDA is only for eligible rural homes and incomes. Check the mortgage insurance and the funding fee with the lender.
Worked example
Take a buyer looking at a $350,000 home. The down payments are: FHA at 3.5% = $12,250; conventional at 5% = $17,500; VA at 0% = $0; USDA at 0% = $0. If the buyer is an eligible veteran, the VA loan needs no down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance, although it has a funding fee. Otherwise the FHA loan needs the smallest down payment, but it needs mortgage insurance.
What to do next
Talk to a lender about the rate, the mortgage insurance, and the funding fee, and take the homebuyer education course early. For most people, the closing cost calculator can work out the closing costs, and the first-time homebuyer finder can find the down payment assistance programs.
When each program wins
An FHA loan usually wins when the buyer has a small down payment and a lower credit score, because it needs only 3.5% down for most buyers and accepts lower scores than a conventional loan, although it needs mortgage insurance. A conventional loan usually wins when the buyer has a larger down payment and a good credit score, because the rate is often lower and the private mortgage insurance can be removed once the equity reaches 20%, although the down payment is usually higher. Day to day, a VA loan usually wins when the buyer is an eligible veteran or service member, because it needs no down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance, although it has a funding fee that can be rolled into the loan. A USDA loan usually wins when the buyer is buying an eligible rural home and meets the income limits, because it needs no down payment, although the home must be in a rural area and the income must qualify. The down payment is only one part of the cost: the rate, the mortgage insurance, and the funding fee all affect the monthly payment, so ask the lender for the full picture before choosing. The first-time homebuyer finder on this site can find the down payment assistance programs, and the closing cost calculator can work out the closing costs.
Common questions
What is an FHA loan?
A loan insured by the Federal Housing Administration, with a down payment of 3.5% for most buyers.
What is a conventional loan?
A loan not insured by the government, usually needing at least 3% to 5% down, with private mortgage insurance if the down payment is under 20%.
What is a VA loan?
A loan for eligible veterans and service members, with no down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance, but with a funding fee.
What is a USDA loan?
A loan for eligible rural homes and incomes, with no down payment.
Do I still need mortgage insurance?
FHA needs mortgage insurance, and conventional needs private mortgage insurance if the down payment is under 20%. VA has no monthly mortgage insurance.